This really has me scratching my head... So lets test a couple of things: Record some guitar/wah licks, and then: Route the *recorded* MIDI (from the 2nd track) to a 3rd track, and arm that 3rd track to record MIDI. Disarm your original tracks, and hit the record button on the transport. - If you are sending/routing MIDI, Reaper should record the MIDI coming out of the 2nd track into the 3rd track. -If you get MIDI recorded, the problem is that your VST is not responding to MIDI (for whatever reason). -If you don't get MIDI recorded into the new track, then somehow, the MIDI routing isn't happening. We're not trying to make it "work" at this point, but trying to isolate the problem.